10 Best Substitute For Bacardi 151

Bacardi 151 was a very strong and popular type of rum, known for its high alcohol content of 75.5% by volume. It was used in cocktails that needed a powerful kick and was even used in some cooking recipes that called for rum. Unfortunately for fans, Bacardi decided to stop making Bacardi 151 in 2016. Since then, people who enjoyed its unique qualities have been searching for other options that could replace it.

If you’re looking for something similar to Bacardi 151, you want a rum or a spirit that is high in alcohol, has a rich flavor, and is versatile for use in drinks or cooking. This blog post will introduce you to ten different substitutes for Bacardi 151. Each one has its own qualities that make it a good replacement, depending on what you need it for. Let’s explore these options together.

10 Best Substitute For Bacardi 151

1. Lemon Hart 151

One of the most popular substitute for Bacardi 151 is Lemon Hart 151. This is a strong, overproof rum that has a similar alcohol content to Bacardi 151—about 75.5%. It has a deep, rich flavor that makes it perfect for mixed drinks that need a little extra strength. Lemon Hart 151 is a good choice if you’re making tiki cocktails, such as a Mai Tai or a Zombie, where the rum’s strong flavor stands out.

Lemon Hart 151 has a distinctive taste with notes of caramel, spice, and a hint of fruitiness. It’s a solid option for those who enjoyed the intense punch of Bacardi 151. However, because of its high alcohol content, be careful when using it—just like Bacardi 151, it should be used in small amounts.

2. Goslings Black Seal 151

Another good alternative is Goslings Black Seal 151. This is also a high-proof rum with an alcohol content of 75.5%. It has a smooth and slightly sweet flavor, with hints of caramel and spice. Goslings Black Seal 151 is often used in dark and stormy cocktails, as well as in other mixed drinks that need a strong rum base.

Goslings Black Seal 151 works well in both cocktails and cooking. If you’re making a dessert or a sauce that calls for a strong rum, this one can add the flavor and kick you’re looking for. Just like with other high-proof spirits, it’s best to use Goslings Black Seal 151 in moderation.

3. Cruzan 151

Cruzan 151 is another overproof rum that can serve as a substitute for Bacardi 151. It has an alcohol content of 75.5% and a lighter, slightly fruity flavor. Cruzan 151 is popular in tropical and tiki-style cocktails, and its lighter taste makes it a versatile option for mixed drinks.

Cruzan 151 works well if you need a strong rum that doesn’t overpower the other ingredients in your cocktail. It is also an affordable choice, which makes it a favorite for people who need a substitute for Bacardi 151 without breaking the bank. As with any overproof rum, remember to handle it with care.

4. Plantation O.F.T.D.

Plantation O.F.T.D. is an overproof rum that has become popular among bartenders and home mixologists. With an alcohol content of 69%, it’s slightly less strong than Bacardi 151, but it still packs a punch. This rum is a blend of rums from different countries, including Jamaica, Guyana, and Barbados, giving it a complex and rich flavor.

Plantation O.F.T.D. has notes of coffee, spices, and a touch of sweetness, making it an excellent choice for tiki drinks. It can add depth and complexity to cocktails, while still giving that overproof kick. If you’re looking for a rum that has a rich taste and can replace Bacardi 151 in your recipes, Plantation O.F.T.D. is a good option.

Read also, 10 Best Substitute For Pinot Noir

5. Don Q 151

Don Q 151 is a strong rum with an alcohol content of 75.5%, making it a suitable substitute for Bacardi 151. It is made in Puerto Rico and has a similar high proof, which makes it ideal for cocktails that require a powerful rum. Don Q 151 has a clean, slightly sweet flavor that blends well with mixers and other ingredients.

This rum is a popular choice for making flaming cocktails, like the Flaming Dr. Pepper, because of its high alcohol content. If you’re looking for a Bacardi 151 replacement for party drinks or cocktails with a dramatic flair, Don Q 151 could be a perfect choice.

6. Wray & Nephew White Overproof Rum

Wray & Nephew White Overproof Rum is a well-known Jamaican rum that has an alcohol content of 63%. While it’s not as strong as Bacardi 151, it’s still very powerful and can be used as a substitute in many cocktails. Wray & Nephew has a bold, fruity flavor with hints of banana and tropical fruits, which makes it a great addition to tropical drinks.

This rum is also popular in cooking, especially in Caribbean recipes that call for a splash of rum. Although it doesn’t have the same dark, intense flavor as Bacardi 151, Wray & Nephew adds a bright and fruity touch that can work well in many dishes and drinks.

7. Hamilton 151 Demerara Rum

Hamilton 151 Demerara Rum is another great substitute for Bacardi 151. It has an alcohol content of 75.5%, making it just as strong, and it’s made from Demerara sugar, which gives it a rich and slightly smoky flavor. Hamilton 151 is known for its complex taste, with notes of caramel, toffee, and spice.

This rum works well in tiki-style drinks, where its depth of flavor can add something special. It’s also a good choice for cooking, especially in recipes that call for a strong, flavorful rum. Hamilton 151 is a good option if you want a rum that has a rich, dark flavor similar to Bacardi 151.

8. Sunset Very Strong Rum

Sunset Very Strong Rum is a rum from Saint Vincent with an alcohol content of 84.5%, which makes it even stronger than Bacardi 151. This rum is not for the faint of heart—it is one of the strongest rums available on the market. It has a clean, somewhat sharp flavor that works well in cocktails where you need a powerful spirit.

If you’re using Sunset Very Strong Rum as a substitute for Bacardi 151, it’s important to be careful due to its high alcohol content. A little goes a long way, and it should always be used in moderation. Sunset Very Strong Rum is a good choice if you need a substitute that can provide an extra kick in your drinks.

9. Stroh 160

Stroh 160 is an Austrian rum with an alcohol content of 80%. It has a distinct flavor, with notes of vanilla, caramel, and spices. Stroh 160 is often used in baking and cooking, especially in Austrian and German recipes, but it can also be used as a substitute for Bacardi 151 in cocktails.

The flavor of Stroh 160 is different from traditional Caribbean rums, but it adds a unique touch to drinks and recipes. If you want a substitute that brings something a little different, while still providing the strength of Bacardi 151, Stroh 160 is a good option to consider.

Read also, 11 Best Substitutes For Amer Picon

10. Everclear

Everclear is a grain alcohol that comes in different strengths, including 151 proof. While it’s not technically a rum, it can be used as a substitute for Bacardi 151 in some cases. Everclear has a neutral flavor, which makes it versatile for mixing into cocktails, but it lacks the rich taste that rum brings.

If you’re looking for a high-proof alcohol that can add strength to a drink without affecting the flavor too much, Everclear 151 can work. Just be aware that it doesn’t have the same depth of flavor as Bacardi 151, so it may not be the best choice for all recipes.

Conclusion

Bacardi 151 was a favorite among many because of its high alcohol content and bold flavor. While it’s no longer available, there are still plenty of options out there that can serve as substitutes. Whether you’re making a tiki cocktail, a flaming drink, or a dish that calls for a strong rum, the ten substitutes listed above can help you recreate the experience of Bacardi 151.